A Comparison of Myths in Different Eras

Mythology is a huge part of Western literary tradition for the explanation that nineteenth centuries, throughout centuries of myth-making, myths originate from completely different eras. Myths from different components of history share a good quantity of dissimilarities. Stories like the Greek God of the Ocean Poseidon, the creature Sphinx are prime examples of myths that originated from the previous. The time period “mythopoeia” was defined in 1931 by J. R. R. Tolkien, during which he adopted it as a title for certainly one of his poems. Through the 2 tales: “The Handsomest Drowned Man within the World” by Gabriel Garcia Márquez and “The Drowned Giant” by J.

G. Ballard, the distinction between myths created in different times is apparent. The focus of the distinction of the 2 tales, during which they take place in two totally different eras would be further discussed.

Myths had been usually created in the early ages of civilization as tales representing people’s concepts and thoughts while myth-making is intently related to completely different trendy social phenomena.

Back in the nineteenth century, folks create legendary gods and creatures that categorical themselves and characterize part of humanity. Greek legendary gods are a main example that portrays the individuals of historical Greek. Greek gods despite being superior to mankind, behave equally to mortals. They quarrel with each other like humans in beauty contests, thirst for want like men are drawn to Aphrodite’s magnificence, provokes jealousy as Hera banning Leto from giving birth and fight with one another just like the competitors of Apollo and Marsyas.

Both “The Iliad” and “The Odyssey” by Homer depicts the brutal conflicts of Greek gods through occasions like the autumn of Troy and the Trojan War. The comparable personalities of god and males present that historic myths are written within the representation of the people. Similar to “The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World” which speaks of the villagers and this represents the folks through the 60s who possess compassion for the world simply as the villagers are to the drowned giant. Myths from current years nevertheless contain less of those primitive parts which are vastly fictional, but quite legendary backgrounds that characterize the society of the modern age.

In “The Drowned Giant”, the writer makes use of the audience for instance of society, where individuals usually assume for themselves but not for others. Children toppling on prime of the lifeless giant, companies utilizing his severed limb for profit both characterize the fashionable society, during which each man is for themselves. As seen, myths created in the past are majorly used to painting the considering of its people, whereas myth being closer to the modern age pertains to the totally different social occurrences of newer times.

Myths set in former times usually contain spiritual components, in distinction to these set in close years. Medieval mythology is usually associated with religion as non secular stories are typically thought-about as myths. Stories like the start of Jesus Christ in Christianity and the clay figures of human by Nu Wa in Chinese mythology both represents religion from its respective cultures. Religion, a theme frequently utilized in myths is unusual in tales like “The Drowned Man” as it’s set in recent times. Well-known people tale “Adam and Eve” within the Book of Genesis, in close relation with Christianity, speaks of the origin of humankind where God created the two people within the Garden of Eden, reinforces the knowledge that myths are correlated with religion. Myths in modern days rarely consist of religious parts. “Myth and Philosophy: A Contest of Truths” by Lawrence J. Hatab speaks of historic Greek myths and that earlier Greek myths make use of religion which later transforms into Greek philosophy.

Modern myths, setting in fashionable age society, accommodates much less spiritual parts evaluating to historical myths. Dissimilar from historic times, having a variance of religions within the fashionable age, religion just isn’t considered as the major subject for myths setting in later instances. Villagers in “The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World” treat the drowned giant with religious practices. Women admire him and see him as a form of a saint, where they offer him the name Esteban and a correct burial. These acts are as a end result of compassion of villagers and that they deal with him like he’s a form of a saint. “The Drowned Giant” however, doesn’t contain spiritual components or hints that resemble the assorted religions of its people. The creator J. G. Ballad whereas uses the habits of various characters to express the mind of modern-day society doesn’t make use of religious parts within the story. Myths set in earlier instances, make use of religion elements extra whereas these set nearer to the modern age forgoes the use of spiritual components. Thereby, myths being set in different eras inevitably contributes to differences by means of religious features.

Myths set in different elements of historical past in reality share a sure likeness in their origin and backgrounds. In which they both make use of the odd and the unknown. Both tales communicate of giants, a mythical being that is purely fictional in our on an everyday basis world. Though both stories are set at completely different occasions, their identical theme means that each stories make the most of the fictional in terms of characters. Ancient legendary characters like Beowulf slaying the nice dragon and the Hound of Ulster Cú Chulainn are all fictional beings in myths from different ages of historical past. As seen, myths set in different occasions shares similarities by way of the use of fanciful characters. In “The Handsomest Drowned Man within the World”, the ladies and men are awed by the enormous and his excellent handsomeness, much more in order that the giant is a being that they never encountered before.

The drowned large being a legendary being, modified the lifestyle for the villagers that they’ve compassion for the useless big who could should reside a better life with his superb handsomeness. “The Drowned Giant” on the opposite hand, uses the giant to present how individuals benefit from the large by using him as a type of leisure, a determine for sightseeing, a product for various corporations. The creator uses the legendary big as a canvas illustrating the people’s attitude towards the lifeless large, which their curiosity has transformed to their selfishness of gaining revenue as a substitute of treating the giant with respect just like the villagers did. The author sets the story realistically where it reflects our modern-day society. Similar publications such as “The Mark of Athena” and “The House of Hades” portrays modern-day mythology as the stories are set within the modern age, the place the legendary story coincides with modern-day characters. As shown, “The Drowned Giant” relates to modern-day social norms unlike “The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World”, which traces back to dated occasions in the past.

Ultimately, the distinction between myths in the two stories is that they happen in several eras. The former sets in a village in the past while the latter sets in a contemporary age where it correlates with our modern society. The two completely different stories regardless of uses the same theme of mythical characters are set in several eras throughout historical past. As seen the two tales being in numerous intervals of history, have influenced the two distinct kinds of writing and the representation of the myth. Thereby, the variations between “The Handsomest Drowned Man within the World” and “The Drowned Giant” are primarily contributed by the two contrasting settings in each story, one being within the former historical past, whereas the other within the trendy age.

Works Cited

  1. Ballard, J. G. “The Drowned Giant” Chronopolis: and other tales. Putnam, 1971.
  2. Homer, and E. V. Rieu. The Odyssey. Methuen, 1952.
  3. Homer, and William Cowper. The Odyssey of Homer. J.M. Dent & Sons, Ltd., 1910.
  4. J.R.R. Tolkien: Mythopoeia. 5th March 2010
  5. Márquez, Gabriel Garcia. “The Handsomest Drowned Man within the World” Leaf storm and other tales. Perennial Classics, 1972.
We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply